It seems like you used my ntsc-rs library for quite a bit of this.
I would like to note that while the ntsc-rs library is permissively licensed, the ntsc-rs-web repository (which implements the web UI) is not.
There appears to be quite a bit of code in this app which has been taken from ntsc-rs-web. Not only does the Rust-side wasm-bindgen wrapper appear to have been copied, but a lot of the architecture seems...heavily inspired by ntsc-rs-web. Can you clarify exactly how much you had Claude look at ntsc-rs-web when designing this?
It looks like someone that doesn't know how VHS looked thinks it looks; text and any other overlay should also be passed thru filter at the very least, and they are too small (would look like blurry mess at VHS resolution)
As someone who was around in the vhs days and has also written filters to approximate vhs, you are correct this is a very poor imitation of how vhs looked.
> The effect is based on ntsc-rs, which simulates how analogue video is encoded and recorded: colour bleed, tracking noise and soft detail, not a picture laid on top.
It looks like they just took ntsc-rs, added a bunch of SEO text, and did not link back to it in any way.
I can’t reply to OP because that comment is dead and I don’t see a reply link on it.
It doesn’t look like how I remember VHS but I think that, other than finding a setup that works (crt included), you probably won’t get useful feedback from people who were around at the time.
In any case, this really does look like a digital filter to me and not like how I remember VHS (I watched those in both ntsc and pal n, and with adapters meant for those who snuggled ntsc hardware into pal n countries).
I can’t find the link now but recently there was a post here about a GitHub
Project that takes an audio file as input and gives you as output an audio file as the original would have sounded in some specific cassettes and let me tell you, that one also didn’t sound at all like the originals (I feel more authoritative on this because I still have working hardware).
This creates a paradox as live video, as would be the case with a broadcast/video call, didn’t go through tape. The discerning viewer would pick up on that and think you’re blowing them off by playing back a pre-recorded one-sided interaction.
The effect is more sentimental when applied to older videos, but that’s only because it’s what millennials are used to.
I would like to note that while the ntsc-rs library is permissively licensed, the ntsc-rs-web repository (which implements the web UI) is not.
There appears to be quite a bit of code in this app which has been taken from ntsc-rs-web. Not only does the Rust-side wasm-bindgen wrapper appear to have been copied, but a lot of the architecture seems...heavily inspired by ntsc-rs-web. Can you clarify exactly how much you had Claude look at ntsc-rs-web when designing this?
It looks like they just took ntsc-rs, added a bunch of SEO text, and did not link back to it in any way.
It doesn’t look like how I remember VHS but I think that, other than finding a setup that works (crt included), you probably won’t get useful feedback from people who were around at the time.
In any case, this really does look like a digital filter to me and not like how I remember VHS (I watched those in both ntsc and pal n, and with adapters meant for those who snuggled ntsc hardware into pal n countries).
I can’t find the link now but recently there was a post here about a GitHub Project that takes an audio file as input and gives you as output an audio file as the original would have sounded in some specific cassettes and let me tell you, that one also didn’t sound at all like the originals (I feel more authoritative on this because I still have working hardware).
The effect is more sentimental when applied to older videos, but that’s only because it’s what millennials are used to.