The seven hour explosion nobody could explain

(phys.org)

55 points | by mellosouls 4 days ago

5 comments

  • saltcured 28 minutes ago
    If this were a scifi horror story, it would be that there was a high energy event so far away and so long ago that the protracted duration is due to red-shift. Those X-rays were actually unimaginably higher energy particles and the duration of the event was also brief but has gotten smeared over time by inflation.
  • purplejacket 2 hours ago
    The paper on which the article is based,

    https://watermark02.silverchair.com/stag328.pdf?token=AQECAH...

    mentions 3 three alternative interpretations for GRB 250702B:

    1. Ultralong Collapsars: These stellar-engine models can explain long durations but struggle to account for the specific timing of this event. Specifically, they cannot easily produce a 12-hour gradual rise in X-rays followed by a multi-hour peak, as the jet would have to fight through a massive progenitor star while its power is still very low.

    2. White Dwarf (WD) Tidal Disruptions: While an Intermediate Mass Black Hole (IMBH) disrupting a White Dwarf could theoretically provide the necessary gravity, the numbers do not add up for this specific burst. The timing between flares is too long for a WD scenario, and the total energy required would demand an unrealistically narrow jet. When physical constraints like detonation are factored in, this model is considered highly unlikely.

    3. Micro-TDEs (Main Sequence star by a stellar-mass BH/NS): This is considered a competitive alternative that can explain the burst's sub-second variability and long duration. However, it faces two main issues: current afterglow data suggests the surrounding gas density matches an IMBH environment better than a micro-TDE environment, and the burst’s extreme energy would require very high jet efficiency or a very narrow beam.

  • Heer_J 1 hour ago
    [dead]
  • comrade1234 2 hours ago
    tldr: it was the office microwave.

    (just kidding - probably a black hole)

  • carlsborg 1 hour ago
    3I/ATLAS first detected on: July 1 2025

    Gamma ray burst that kept going for seven hours, fired three distinct bursts spread across an entire day: July 2 2025

    just saying

    • EA-3167 1 hour ago
      This event originated in a different galaxy.